Don\u2019t Call the Cops If You\u2019re Autistic, Deaf, Mentally Ill, Disabled or Old<\/p>\n
By John W. Whitehead
\nOctober 24, 2017<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
\u201cAnyone who cares for someone with a developmental disability, as well as for disabled people themselves\u00a0[lives] every day in fear<\/a>\u00a0that their behavior will be misconstrued as suspicious, intoxicated or hostile by law enforcement.\u201d\u2014Steve Silberman,\u00a0The New York Times<\/em><\/p><\/blockquote>\n
Life in the American police state is an endless series of don\u2019ts delivered at the end of a loaded gun: don\u2019t talk back to police officers, don\u2019t even think about defending yourself against a SWAT team raid (of which there are 80,000 every year), don\u2019t run when a cop is nearby lest you be mistaken for a fleeing criminal, don\u2019t carry a cane lest it be mistaken for a gun, don\u2019t expect privacy in public, don\u2019t let your kids walk to the playground alone, don\u2019t engage in nonviolent protest near where a government official might pass, don\u2019t try to grow vegetables in your front yard, don\u2019t play music for tips in a metro station, don\u2019t feed whales, and on and on.<\/p>\n
Here\u2019s another don\u2019t to the add the growing list of things that could get you or a loved one tasered, shot or killed, especially if you are autistic, hearing impaired, mentally ill, elderly, suffer from dementia, disabled or have any other condition that might hinder your ability to understand, communicate or immediately comply with an order: don\u2019t call the cops.<\/p>\n
Sometimes it\u2019s dangerous enough calling the cops when you\u2019re not contending with a disability.<\/p>\n
For instance, Justine\u00a0Damond called 911 to report a disturbance and ended up dead<\/a>\u00a0after police dispatched to investigate instead shot the 40-year-old yoga instructor. Likewise, Carl Williams\u00a0called 911 to report a robbery and ended up being shot by police<\/a>, who mistook him for a robber in his own home.<\/p>\n
Unfortunately, the risks just skyrocket when a disability is involved.<\/p>\n
Nancy Schrock\u00a0called 911 for help after her husband, Tom, who suffered with mental health issues, started stalking around the backyard, upending chairs and screaming about demons<\/a>. Several times before, police had transported Tom to the hospital, where he was medicated and sent home after 72 hours. This time, Tom was tasered twice. He collapsed, lost consciousness and died.<\/p>\n
The Schrocks are not alone in this experience.<\/p>\n
Indeed,\u00a0disabled individuals make up a third to half of all people killed by law enforcement officers.<\/a><\/p>\n
That\u2019s according to a study by the Ruderman Family Foundation,\u00a0 which reports that \u201cdisabled individuals make up the majority of those killed in use-of-force cases<\/a>\u00a0that attract widespread attention. This is true both for cases deemed illegal or against policy and for those in which officers are ultimately fully exonerated\u2026 Many more disabled civilians experience non-lethal violence and abuse at the hands of law enforcement officers.\u201d<\/p>\n
Trained to shoot first and ask questions later, police pose a risk to anyone with special needs whose disabilities may not be immediately apparent or require more finesse than the typical freeze-or-I\u2019ll-shoot tactics employed by America\u2019s police forces.<\/p>\n
For example, in South Carolina, police tasered an 86-year-old grandfather reportedly in the early stages of dementia,\u00a0while he was jogging backwards away from them<\/a>. Now this happened after Albert Chatfield led police on a car chase, running red lights and turning randomly. However, at the point that police chose to shock the old man with electric charges, he was out of the car, on his feet, and outnumbered by police officers much younger than him.<\/p>\n
In Georgia, campus police shot and killed a 21-year-old student who was suffering a mental health crisis. Scout\u00a0Schultz was shot through the heart<\/a>\u00a0by campus police when he approached four of them late one night while holding a pocketknife, shouting \u201cShoot me!\u201d Although police may have feared for their lives, the blade was still in its closed position.<\/p>\n
In Oklahoma, police\u00a0shot and killed a 35-year-old deaf man<\/a>\u00a0seen holding a two-foot metal pipe on his front porch (he used the pipe to fend off stray dogs while walking). Despite the fact that witnesses warned police that Magdiel Sanchez couldn\u2019t hear\u2014and thus comply\u2014with their shouted orders to drop the pipe and get on the ground, police shot the man when he was about 15 feet away from them.<\/p>\n
In Maryland,\u00a0police (moonlighting as security guards) used extreme force to eject a 26-year-old man with Downs Syndrome and a low IQ<\/a>\u00a0from a movie theater after the man insisted on sitting through a second screening of a film. Autopsy results indicate that Ethan Saylor died of complications arising from asphyxiation, likely caused by a chokehold.<\/p>\n
In Florida,\u00a0police armed with assault rifles fired three shots at a 27-year-old nonverbal, autistic man<\/a>\u00a0who was sitting on the ground, playing with a toy truck. Police missed the autistic man and instead shot his behavioral therapist, Charles Kinsey, who had been trying to get him back to his group home. The therapist,\u00a0bleeding from a gunshot wound<\/a>, was then handcuffed and left lying face down on the ground for 20 minutes.<\/p>\n
In Texas,\u00a0police handcuffed, tasered and then used a baton to subdue a 7-year-old student who has severe ADHD and a mood disorder<\/a>. With school counselors otherwise occupied, school officials called police and the child\u2019s mother to assist after Yosio Lopez started banging his head on a wall. The police arrived first.<\/p>\n
In New Mexico,\u00a0police tasered, then opened fire on a 38-year-old homeless man who suffered from schizophrenia<\/a>, all in an attempt to get James Boyd to leave a makeshift campsite. Boyd\u2019s death provoked a wave of protests over heavy-handed law enforcement tactics.<\/p>\n
In Ohio,\u00a0police forcefully subdued a 37-year-old bipolar woman<\/a>\u00a0wearing only a nightgown in near-freezing temperatures who was neither armed, violent, intoxicated, nor suspected of criminal activity. After being slammed onto the sidewalk, handcuffed and left unconscious on the street, Tanisha Anderson died as a result of being restrained in a prone position.<\/p>\n
And in North Carolina, a\u00a0state trooper shot and killed a 29-year-old deaf motorist<\/a>\u00a0after he failed to pull over during a traffic stop. Daniel K. Harris was shot after exiting his car, allegedly because the trooper\u00a0feared he might be reaching for a weapon<\/a>.<\/p>\n
These cases, and the hundreds\u2014if not thousands\u2014more that go undocumented every year speak to a crisis in policing when it comes to law enforcement\u2019s failure to adequately assess, de-escalate and manage encounters with special needs or disabled individuals.<\/p>\n
While the research is relatively scant, what has been happening is telling.<\/p>\n
Over the course of six months,\u00a0police shot and killed someone who was in mental crisis every 36 hours<\/a>.<\/p>\n
Among\u00a0124 police killings analyzed by\u00a0The Washington Post\u00a0<\/em>in which mental illness appeared to be a factor<\/a>, \u201cThey were overwhelmingly men, more than half of them white. Nine in 10 were armed with some kind of weapon, and most died close to home.\u201d<\/p>\n
But there were also important distinctions,\u00a0reports<\/a>\u00a0the\u00a0Post<\/em>.<\/p>\n
\u201cThis group was more likely to wield a weapon less lethal than a firearm.<\/a>\u00a0Six had toy guns; 3 in 10 carried a blade, such as a knife or a machete \u2014 weapons that rarely prove deadly to police officers. According to data maintained by the FBI and other organizations, only three officers have been killed with an edged weapon in the past decade. Nearly a dozen of the mentally distraught people killed were military veterans, many of them suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of their service, according to police or family members. Another was a former California Highway Patrol officer who had been forced into retirement after enduring a severe beating during a traffic stop that left him suffering from depression and PTSD.\u00a0And in 45 cases, police were called to help someone get medical treatment, or after the person had tried and failed to get treatment on his own.<\/a>\u201d<\/p><\/blockquote>\n
The U.S. Supreme Court, as might be expected, has thus far continued to immunize police against charges of wrongdoing when it comes to use of force against those with a mental illness.<\/p>\n
In a 2015 ruling, the Court declared that\u00a0police could not be sued for forcing their way into a mentally ill woman\u2019s room at a group home and shooting her five times when she advanced on them them with a knife<\/a>. The justices did not address whether police must take special precautions when arresting mentally ill individuals. (The\u00a0Americans with Disabilities <\/a>Act<\/a>requires \u201creasonable accommodations\u201d for people with mental illnesses, which in this case might have been less confrontational tactics.)<\/p>\n
Where does this leave us?<\/p>\n
For starters, we need better police training across the board, but especially when it comes to de-escalation tactics and crisis intervention.<\/p>\n
A study by the National Institute of Mental Health found that CIT (Crisis Intervention Team)-trained officers made fewer arrests, used less force, and connected more people with mental-health services<\/a>\u00a0than their non-trained peers.<\/p>\n
As\u00a0The Washington Post\u00a0<\/em>points out:<\/p>\n
\u201cAlthough new recruits typically spend nearly 60 hours learning to handle a gun, according to a recent survey by the Police Executive Research Forum, they receive only eight hours of training to de-escalate tense situations and eight hours learning strategies for handling the mentally ill. Otherwise,\u00a0police are taught to employ tactics that tend to be counterproductive in such encounters<\/a>, experts said. For example, most officers are trained to seize control when dealing with an armed suspect, often through stern, shouted commands. But yelling and pointing guns is \u2018like pouring gasoline on a fire when you do that with the mentally ill,\u2019 said Ron Honberg, policy director with the National Alliance on Mental Illness.\u201d<\/p><\/blockquote>\n
Second, police need to\u00a0learn how to slow confrontations down<\/a>, instead of ramping up the tension (and the noise).<\/p>\n
After Ethan Saylor\u2019s death in Maryland, police recruits are now required to take a four-hour course in which they learn \u201cde-escalation tactics\u201d for dealing with disabled individuals:\u00a0speak calmly, give space, be patient<\/a>.<\/p>\n
One officer in charge of the Los Angeles Police Department\u2019s \u201cmental response teams\u201d suggests that instead of rushing to take someone into custody,\u00a0police should try to slow things down and persuade the person to come with them<\/a>.<\/p>\n
Third, with all the questionable funds flowing to police departments these days, why not use some of those funds to establish what one disability-rights activist describes as \u201ca 911-type number dedicated to handling mental-health emergencies<\/a>, with community crisis-response teams at the ready rather than police officers.\u201d<\/p>\n
In the end, while we need to make encounters with police officers safer for people with disabilities, what we really need is to make encounters with police safer for citizens across the board, no matter how they\u2019re packaged.<\/p>\n
As I point out in my book\u00a0Battlefield America: The War on the American People<\/em><\/a>, the problem is not that police officers are inherently bad\u2014in fact, there are many good, caring officers in law enforcement\u2014but when cops are trained to be military warriors instead of peace officers, we\u2019re all viewed as potential threats.<\/p>\n
SOURCE:<\/p>\n