Myart’s remains
Disenfranchised seek new legal counsel after in-your-face Civil
Rights attorney is sidelined
Justin Parr
Helen Hullaby with a photo of niece Terry Woods.
Greg Harman
Another loss for Brenda Shaw and John McCalister Sr.
By Greg Harman
It could have been a 12-step program gathered in the basement meeting
room of Mt. Zion Baptist Church. There was no shortage of tears,
anguish, or exhaustion. But the demons this gathering was bonding over
weren’t those of personal or family addiction, but the more abusive
elements within San Antonio’s Police Department.
In the slow slog for justice, the January hearing on police practices
wasn’t intended to rile television audiences or mobilize a simmering
crowd, it is a time to speak and be heard.
A panel from the Police Executive Research Forum have their faces
buried in legal pads at the back of the room, their fingers knotted
over yellow sheaves of paper. They’ve been retained by Police Chief
William McManus to investigate his department’s use-of-force
policies, both on paper and in practice.
After meeting with the ruling caste the night before and scavenging
police files, they are on San Antonio’s East Side tonight to get the
report from the street.
One after another, those bearing wounds they claim were inflicted by
members of the SAPD take to the front of the room and share their
grief, anger, and confusion.
A young man talks about having his pants pulled to his ankles at a
city service station. In front of numerous witnesses, the man says he
was penetrated by SAPD contraband-seeking latex.
“Ever since then it’s kind of hard to talk about it,” he tells
the PERF representatives seated at a folding table up center, as
dozens of others crowd around listening. “To me, it’s sexual
assault. This cannot be right. This cannot be the way things are
done.”
The stories of these self-identified victims and their families
suggest it is — in too many cases — exactly that.
For years, these were the stories Civil Rights attorney James
Myart’s practice guaranteed prominent placement on regional
newscasts, local radio, and in untold inches of newsprint.
Moving about the room in a wide-cut suit, Myart was operating with
uncharacteristic tenderness, circulating among clients, exchanging
muted words with attendees, and offering handshakes all around. It is
a potential watershed moment, capping years of his own efforts to draw
attention to what he considers a cancer in San Antonio law
enforcement. A positive outcome here will almost excuse his episodic
tirades, out-and-out tantrums, and innumerable slights and slurs.
Brenda Shaw describes how a family disturbance call unraveled because
of bully police tactics, resulting in her whole family being violently
cuffed. How her daughter Lakisha McCalister was dropped facedown in a
pile of rocks and battered. Of the seizures that started thereafter.
Sobbing, Lakisha tells the group, “I don’t know why I have
seizures. And I’m going to have them for the rest of my life.”
“It needs to change,” Shaw pleads with the PERF board. “It
starts with y’all, because y’all are an outside agency.”
PERF describes itself as a collection of “progressive police
executives from the largest city, county and state law enforcement
agencies,” dedicated to “improving policing and advancing
professionalism through research and involvement in public policy
debate.”
Under pressure from mounting complaints about its officers, the City
commissioned PERF to conduct a use-of-force report on the SAPD. Though
expected in the spring, those findings were only submitted to Chief
McManus two weeks ago. After the department has drafted its response
to the report, the package will be presented to the City Council and
the now-simmering debate will be fed a fresh cord of kindling.
SAPD spokesperson Sergeant Gabe Treviño said McManus would not be
commenting on the report or on Myart, referring questions to the City
Attorney’s office. “Obviously, the police department has systems
in place for citizens to complain and express their concerns when they
have a complaint against a police officer,” Treviño said. “There
might be some tweaking of some of those things, with what the PERF
recommendations may have, but I think those systems are in place and
are effective… with some minor adjustments.”
One thing is certain, the iconic face of antagonistic resistance,
James Myart, won’t have any part in the drama that will unfold from
here. It’s lamentable.
I have to confess, I liked the bomb-chucking attorney from the start
— from the first press conference I attended.
The City had just offered an $80,000 settlement to a young black man
whose scalp was split by an SAPD bullet. After being stopped on his
way to work, Joseph Fennell said he removed a set of keys from his
pocket. He was matched with a shot to the head.
After snapping pics of Fennell and Myart for a good 20 minutes, I
started taking a few shots of the back of the room — the many
television cameras and reporters grouped behind me. A scribbler from
the Express-News brayed his objection, demanding I not take his
picture.
Needless to say, the press conference stopped. The outburst cut into
Myart’s presentation, which, to this point, had included his tossing
a thick binder of associated police records of the incident onto the
floor in a show of contempt. The showman blasted the other writer and
instructed him to get out of the room.
A snap judgment. A loud — and (to me) righteouss — command.
I’ve enjoyed his other eruptions almost equally.
There have been few local attorneys, for instance, willing to take
their charges of racist police behavior before such expectantly
unappreciative audiences as FOX News duo Hannity and Colmes. Fewer
still eager to unload on national television gems like: “Mr.
Hannity, again, as I told you, you’re just a rich, white boy who
will never understand,” as Myart did in November 2006 during a
segment headlined, “Do police target African-Americans?”
For the crowd at Mt. Zion, the question wasn’t even worth asking.
Myart, the 300-pound pontiff of black justice, was the voice on the
mountain when it came to Civil Rights in this decidedly uncivil town.
Even those in disagreement with him at that meeting knew him at least
as a man of action.
But Myart’s oversize zest for insinuation and disparagement in his
war on the establishment caught up with him — repeatedly.
His attorney’s license was pulled for four years in 1999 on charges
of professional misconduct. In April, he earned another three-year
suspension for aggravated perjury. Only a few weeks later a jubilant
press release scrolled out of the Current fax, blaring, “‘CIVIL
RIGHTS’ ATTORNEY JAMES MYART ADMITS TO CRIMINAL WRONGS.”
As part of a plea deal, Myart pleaded guilty to not only stealing
from a Habitat for Humanity store in 2005 and filing a false report
about being attacked by police officers in 2006, but also to charges
of pocketing $13,275 from a client.
Compounding his embarrassment, the client he admitted to wronging
turned out to be the reputed founder of the Texas chapter of the
Mexican Mafia, Heriberto “Herbie” Huerta.
Online forum-goers — like one gun site dedicated to the AR-15
machine gun, a police favorite — went ballistic on Myart. Comments
raged from an offer of a noose to rampant speculation on Myart’s
prison life expectancy.
Neither Myart nor his attorney Christopher Gale could be reached for
this article.
Wherever one lines up on Myart’s rebel style — whether you
consider the man rabidly racist himself or heroically uncompromising
— his failings have left a gaping hole, a truly Myart-sized hole, in
San Antonio’s legal network.
Drawn typically from the economic underclass, Myart’s former
clients have fallen into a legal miasma. Some have found their way to
new counsel, thanks to the local American Civil Liberties Union
chapter. Others drift still.
St. Hedwig resident Helen Hullaby was at Zion the day that PERF
members settled into folding chairs to hear from what Myart described
as “a small microcosm” of San Antonio’s mistreated minorities.
Though she paid Myart $5,000 for assistance, Hullaby’s effort to
gain help for her niece — as well as confront the SAPD and a local
hospital — never made it to the starting blocks.
Hullaby’s niece, Terry Lynn Woods, is a 42-year-old deaf woman with
a string of violent behavior to her record. Due to her unpredictable
temper, something Hullaby blames on her deafness and a bi-polar
disorder, Woods is not welcome to stay with family in San Antonio. So
she bounces around the assisted-living circuit.
During a police confrontation at one such residence, Woods didn’t
make it downtown. Instead, she found herself dumped at Nix Specialty
Hospital with a fractured leg.
Hullaby said Woods told her she was having trouble getting her state
disability check and blamed the owner of Rosa’s Assisted Living,
Rosa Toney.
Toney said the fight was over a man talking to Woods’ girlfriend.
“She threw large rocks through all first-floor windows across the
front of house. Cut phone lines. One almost hit a resident,” Toney
said.
The Current was not able to locate a witness to the arrest, but
police records indicate officers were dispatched to the location twice
that day.
Previous calls list Woods as a repeated source of trouble.
There were repeated struggles over her medication and a brick-tossing
incident. Woods was evicted.
In May, Woods returned to the home to pick up her belongings, Hullaby
said. When she arrived she found her belongings piled up outside the
house — but not her check.
That’s when a round of window breaking began.
“I guess they told her to stop or whatever, and she didn’t, so
they caught up with her and they handcuffed her,” Hullaby said.
“They threw her in the back of the car and they just continued to
beat her. Even though she was in handcuffs, they continued to beat
her.”
Toney said the encounter happened up the street and she didn’t see
the arrest.
Officers supposedly then took Woods and dropped her at Nix Specialty
Hospital on Vance Jackson, where she was put in a splint and released.
Hullaby couldn’t find Woods for four weeks, but when she caught up
with her niece, now at another assisted-living residence — one that
Hullaby claims was being run by drug dealers — she found a medical
emergency.
“I saw Terry and her leg was swollen all double,” she said.
Hullaby and others got Woods to an orthopedic surgeon for emergency
treatment.
The aunt’s primary complaint has been with the SAPD and Nix
Hospital, but her hope in hiring Myart was ultimately to get power of
attorney over Woods so she could get her admitted into a state
hospital for long-term care.
“She needs it,” agrees Toney. “She needs it. She is out of
control. She is totally out of control.”
When Myart disappeared with Hullaby’s $5,000, the woman didn’t
know what to do.
“In a way, I feel like he has us in mind, but there is nothing he
can do because he had his license suspended,” Hullaby says. “I
need something to be done because Terry is in another boarding house
and she got into it with the people. She has problems getting along
with people. They called me. They all think that I have guardianship
over her and I don’t.”
Clients who got lost in the Myart shuffle have a couple of options,
says Maureen Ray, special administrative counsel in the Office of
Chief Disciplinary Counsel for the State Bar of Texas. The first is to
call the Bar’s Lawyer Referral Service to get matched with an
attorney working in a field similar to their former lawyer.
Payments made to attorneys who either intentionally pocketed
settlement cash or failed to provide services at all, can be
reimbursed through The Client Security Fund. Amassed from the annual
dues paid each year by practicing Texas attorneys, the Fund cashed out
almost half a million dollars on 27 cases during 2006. Most were cases
of attorneys holding fees they did not earn; 18 were found to be
incidents of theft by the lawyer, according to data maintained by the
Bar.
However, miffed clients can’t claim money they feel they would have
been awarded if their attorneys hadn’t dropped their cases.
Keeping up with their ambulance-chasing image, personal injury
lawyers were responsible for most awards paid out through the Fund.
Many of Myart’s cases were shunted to local ACLU board member Ed
Piña — likely the only other Civil Rights attorney in San Antonio
who handles more cases of alleged police abuse than the now off-screen
Myart.
There were few venues Myart was not willing to rush into with his
vociferous claims of racial profiling and unprovoked police attacks on
African-Americans. Although, his behavior has earned him public
derision and time in jail, such as when he grandstanded at a City
Council meeting, demanding that protestors removed from the meeting be
allowed back into the chambers, some of his colleagues believe such
trumpeting is necessary.
While most attorneys contacted for this story failed to return
repeated phone calls, Piña offered some insights.
“I certainly respect his approach to this,” said Piña. “It’s
a necessary approach, and it probably permitted me not to have to
raise the profile of some of my cases, which otherwise I may have been
required to do in order to effectively represent them.”
Piña is a defender of Myart — at least as far as recent City
actions are concerned. He spoke up for Myart when the disgraced
attorney was arrested at the City Council meeting and smacked with a
restraining order requiring him to stay away from City Hall and Mayor
Phil Hardberger. But he has a far more sedate method of pursuing
justice.
“Mr. Myart and I have always done more civil- rights work than
anybody else I know of, but you know, different tracks in the
sense that I’m always leery of the spotlight,” Piña said. “Now,
sometimes representation of your client absolutely demands
and requires it and I’d be remiss if I didn’t do it. Otherwise,
I’m not going to seek it.”
Myart’s boisterousness was good for other Civil Rights attorneys in
that it communicated the widespread public complaints about the police
force to the public — and the potential jury pool. Myart may be able
to apply for reinstatement with the Texas Bar in five years, but in
the meantime, another public loudspeaker may need to step in.
“I don’t like for people to hear about my cases, but sometimes
it’s necessary,” Piña said. “I think everybody in the Civil
Rights community owes a debt to him, in one way or another.”
Lakisha McCalister was in the house when the police arrived. Her
brothers had been fighting. But John had since gone outside. Her
younger brother retreated to his room.
Then the cops showed up.
John was pulled from the yard and placed face down on the sidewalk,
according to mother Brenda Shaw. Then, one by one, as the family came
out of the house, there was more of the same.
In the ensuing confusion, a disbelieving Shaw recalls a female
officer shoving her way past her and heading at her daughter, who had
cried out, “Look what these pigs are doing to us!”
“She pushed me into the fence and balled up her fists and started
going after Lakisha,” she said.
Her own arm quickly twisted behind her back by another officer, she
watched as Lakisha was slammed face down in a rockpile. As a pile of
blue uniforms fell upon the slight, young girl, she claims to have
seen a fist rise and fall on her daughter.
“I first saw her have a seizure about two weeks later,” Shaw
said. But Lakisha relates that just hours after her arrest for
interfering with police business and assaulting an officer she lost
control of her body.
“She said she first had a seizure in jail. They tied her to a chair
and put a plastic bag over her head. They said, ‘Ah, you’re not
having a seizure. You’re just faking,’” Shaw said.
Her parents say the 20-year-old now takes two medications to control
her episodes.
The PERF report is unlikely to satisfy those who claim mistreatment
by SAPD — and it won’t change the opinions of Brenda Shaw, who not
only blames local police for her daughter’s seizures, but now has to
lament the death of her son, possibly due to a Parks Police officer
taking too long to call EMS after a gang-related shooting late last
month.
(Though the shooting occurred on May 28, the Parks Police report had
still not been filed by this week’s press deadline. SAPD, who
arrived later, reported that two men were arrested for aggravated
assault and aggravated robbery.)
As Myart began to recognize how his own behavior was threatening his
practice, he began to soften, admitting to his own struggles to find
mental clarity. A softspoken Myart closed the PERF meeting in January
with a disclaimer.
“The vast majority of officers are honest, god-fearing, spiritual
human beings,” he said. “But it’s more than a few bad apples,
ladies and gentlemen … This is what you call anarchy in the worst
way.”
If anarchy comes with the territory, it’s no wonder the Myart-sized
hole may be a hard one to fill.
Any takers?
Link: http://sacurrent.com/news/story.asp?id=68871
—
BETTER IP RELAY – EVERYWHERE! i711.com makes all your relay calls better.
Better web calls. Better wireless calls. Better AIM calls. Why settle for
ordinary IP relay? Go beyond! Try http://www.i711.com for free today!
NEW! Try out our Deaf Network of Texas Calendar! Go to
http://calendar.deafnetwork.com
NOTE: deafnetwork.com does not endorse any of the products, vendors,
consultants, or documentation referenced in this message or. Any mention of
vendors, products, or services is for informational purposes only.
Powered by http://www.CrazyWebHosting.com
If you do not want to receive any more newsletters,
http://deafnetwork.com/list/?p=unsubscribe&uid=23e6b0ac27edebd2b6f52f1354859234
To update your preferences and to unsubscribe visit
http://deafnetwork.com/list/?p=preferences&uid=23e6b0ac27edebd2b6f52f1354859234
Forward a Message to Someone
http://deafnetwork.com/list/?p=forward&uid=23e6b0ac27edebd2b6f52f1354859234&mid=1840
—
Powered by PHPlist, www.phplist.com —